Blake A. Hallock

Partner

Utah

   

bhallock@jshfirm.com
TEL: 385.440.7061
FAX: 385.388.7998
Legal Assistant: Mindie Michelson
385.440.7071
mmichelson@jshfirm.com

Blake Hallock defends businesses, insurers, and their insureds in Utah’s state and federal courts, with a particular focus on cases in which the exposure is high, the law is unsettled, or the outcome turns on a dispositive legal issue. Clients and carriers turn to him for the matters that call for more than routine handling: first-party underinsured motorist suits paired with bad faith claims, catastrophic-injury and wrongful death cases, Fair Housing Act suits against housing providers, contract disputes, and appeals. Blake serves as Utah local counsel for national retailers and represents several national insurance carriers and their insureds throughout the state.

Blake’s results come from a disciplined approach to case strategy. He identifies early the issues on which a case will actually turn and builds the defense around them, which has allowed him to end many cases before trial through dispositive motions and to resolve others on favorable terms once the strengths of the defense have been established. He has obtained summary judgment dismissing bad faith claims against insurers in federal court, summary judgment for housing providers facing discrimination and retaliation claims under the federal and Utah Fair Housing Acts, and dismissals of wrongful death claims against recreational businesses based on signed liability waivers. In cases that cannot be won outright, he has resolved catastrophic-injury claims at a small fraction of the claimed exposure. His written advocacy is a central reason for those outcomes, in dispositive motions, in mediation and arbitration briefs, and on appeal.

Blake also maintains an active appellate practice. He has briefed and argued before the Utah Court of Appeals, successfully defending a jury verdict for his client, and he is admitted to practice before the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

Clients rely on Blake for thorough early case evaluations, candid and well-reasoned status reports, and consistent responsiveness. He also mentors, trains, and supervises associates in the firm’s Utah office.

Blake earned his J.D. from Brigham Young University’s J. Reuben Clark Law School, where he was a Clyde F. Worthen Scholar and represented the school in the National Moot Court Competition. In his spare time, he enjoys spending time with his family, skiing, and playing chess.

  • Won affirmance of a no-cause jury verdict in the Utah Court of Appeals. Jaimes v. Arellano-Medina, 2024 UT App 112, 555 P.3d 840. Blake briefed and argued the appeal. Plaintiffs, who had delayed treatment for 39 days after a low-speed collision, argued that the trial court abused its discretion by barring them from telling the jury that their auto insurer initially denied coverage. The Court of Appeals agreed with Blake that the trial court properly weighed the evidence under Rules 403 and 411 of the Utah Rules of Evidence and affirmed the defense verdict.
  • Obtained summary judgment dismissing a bad faith claim against an insurer in a UIM action. Sanders v. Progressive Preferred Insurance Co., No. 2:21-cv-00146, 2023 WL 356437 (D. Utah Jan. 23, 2023). Blake briefed the cross-motions for summary judgment. The court held that the insured’s policy-limits demand was fairly debatable as a matter of law because the need for future medical care was uncertain and the claimed non-economic damages were speculative, and that the insured could not establish damages caused by the alleged bad faith rather than by the accident itself.
  • Obtained summary judgment dismissing bad faith claims with prejudice in a $100,000 UIM dispute. Baker v. Progressive Direct Insurance Co., No. 2:21-cv-00307, 2023 WL 3044954 (D. Utah Apr. 21, 2023). Blake briefed the motion. The court dismissed both bad faith causes of action because the insured failed to establish the fact of damages flowing from the insurer’s claim handling.
  • Obtained summary judgment for a landlord and property manager on Fair Housing Act retaliation and failure-to-accommodate claims. James v. Brim Properties, LLC, No. 240908905 (Utah 3d Dist. Ct., Salt Lake Cnty., Oct. 11, 2025). The court granted the defendants’ motion in its entirety and denied Plaintiff’s cross-motion, holding that the tenant’s communications never put the defendants on notice of a specific disability or a specific accommodation request, that the requested rent deferrals and fee waivers were not accommodations necessary because of a disability, and that the non-renewal of his lease was not retaliatory.
  • Secured the dismissal of a wrongful death action against a recreational boat rental company. Two individuals drowned in a boating incident, and their families sued the rental company. Blake obtained the dismissal of all claims arising from one of the two deaths based on a signed liability waiver, and the remaining claims were dismissed in their entirety on the eve of trial with no payment by the client or its carrier.
  • Resolved a catastrophic-injury premises case for a national retailer at a small fraction of the claimed exposure. Plaintiff suffered catastrophic injuries when she was pinned between two vehicles in the retailer’s parking lot and sued on an unsafe-parking-lot-design theory. She sought damages in excess of $20 million, and the severity of her injuries created realistic trial exposure in that range. Blake resolved the retailer’s share of the case for a small fraction of the demand.

Professional Associations & Memberships

  • Utah State Bar, Litigation Section
  • Utah Defense Lawyers Association

Education

Brigham Young University J. Reuben Clark Law School, J.D., 2019
Clyde F. Worthen Scholar
National Moot Court Representative

Brigham Young University, B.A., Philosophy, 2016

Admissions

Utah
U.S. District Court, District of Utah
U.S. Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit